A Dating Profile Makeover: A Before & After Example

By Sandra · Updated on 29 September 2026 · ✓ Reviewed by the editorial team

A Dating Profile Makeover: A Before & After Example

After 22 years of marriage, Sabine was staring at a blank screen. She'd downloaded a dating app and signed up, but what on earth was she meant to write about herself?

“I'm a nice person who enjoys a good walk”? It sounded boring even to her own ears. So she wrote three safe sentences and uploaded a photo from her last summer holiday, hiding behind sunglasses on a beach.

Three weeks later: not a single match that led to a proper conversation. “Am I simply invisible?”, she wondered.

The answer was simpler than she thought: her profile didn't show the real Sabine, just a stranger hiding behind clichés and holiday snaps.

The essentials

To make your profile on dating apps and sites really shine, swap out tired clichés for specific, personal details and genuine photos.

  • Stand out from the crowd: Great profiles grab attention with real-life details, not the usual clichés.
  • Your photos are key: Up-to-date photos with a real smile – and no sunglasses – often get more interest.
  • Specific beats generic: A description like ‘At the farmers’ market at 7:30 on a Saturday’ has much more impact than just ‘I’m active’.
  • Make the first lines count: On a smartphone, the first couple of lines of your profile are what determine whether someone keeps reading or scrolls on by.
  • Add a few conversation starters: Including details that prompt questions will lead to much better chats.
  • Avoid the common pitfalls: Outdated photos, long lists of requirements, and any negativity are major turn-offs. Being your authentic self is what opens doors.

1. Sabine's story: When your profile gets overlooked

Sabine is an example that sums up what many singles go through; her name and the figures are illustrative.

Sabine, 54, a primary school teacher, gave herself three months after her divorce before signing up to dating sites like Match.com and eHarmony. She didn't want to rush things. She wanted to do it right.

But ‘right’ felt all wrong. Her profile read like a job application: factual, complete, correct – and completely lifeless.

The main photo showed her on a beach in Crete, sunglasses on, hair windswept, her face half in shadow. The bio was just three sentences: ‘I’m a fun-loving person who enjoys travelling and the great outdoors. I’m looking for someone to share new experiences with. Honesty and a sense of humour are important to me.’

Three weeks, 47 profile views, two matches – both fizzled out into one-word chats. Sabine felt invisible.

Not because she was. Her profile showed nothing of what really made her tick: the woman who’d be at the farmers' market by half past seven on a Saturday morning to snag the best tomatoes, who’d been learning Italian for a year, and whose laugh her friends described as ‘infectious’.

Every time she opened the dating app and saw no new messages, it felt like a silent rejection.

‘Maybe I’m just too old for this’, she thought. Until a friend told her: ‘Your profile doesn’t show you. It shows who you think you’re supposed to be.’

That was the turning point.

2. The diagnosis: Why Sabine's profile was being ignored

Sabine's profile had five fundamental flaws – mistakes that many singles make when they get back into dating after a long relationship.

Mistake 1: The hidden face

In her main photo, she’s wearing sunglasses. Profiles where you can’t see the eyes often come across as distant and usually get fewer responses.

We look for eye contact, even online. Those sunglasses sent a subconscious message: "I'm hiding."

Mistake 2: The CV approach

Sabine's bio read like a job advert. ‘Fun-loving woman’ – what does that actually mean? ‘Loves the outdoors’ – who doesn't?

Instead of telling stories, she'd just listed a string of adjectives. No one remembers a profile that says ‘honest and humorous’. But they'll definitely remember one that says, ‘I laugh so loudly at the cinema that strangers end up laughing along with me.’

Mistake 3: Cliché bingo

"Shared experiences", "honesty", "humour" – you'll see these words in countless profiles. They're so common they just fade into the background.

Sabine's profile could have belonged to just about anyone.

Mistake 4: No conversation starter

Nothing in her bio prompted a question. There was no detail for someone to pick up on.

Anyone wanting to message her had to pull an opening line out of thin air.

Mistake 5: Fear of rejection

Sabine had smoothed over her profile so much that all her interesting quirks were gone. She was trying so hard not to put anyone off that she ended up appealing to no one at all.

Her profile played it safe. And on dating sites, playing it safe is the most boring thing you can do.

3. Step 1: Photos that tell your story

A woman sifting through printed photos to choose the perfect one for her dating profile.

Sabine decided not to just ‘improve’ her profile; she decided to rebuild it from scratch. She asked herself one simple question: ‘Would I message myself?’

The answer was a real eye-opener.

She went through her photos, judging each one by a new standard: ‘Does this picture show who I really am, or just how I think I should look?’

Her new main picture

The new main picture was taken on a Saturday afternoon in a friend's garden. Natural light, a genuine smile (yes, with teeth – people with a visible, real smile often get more responses), and no filter.

She was wearing her favourite linen shirt, the one she'd bought in Florence. The picture wasn't perfect; a wisp of hair had fallen across her face, but it was authentic.

The action shots

These pictures showed Sabine in her element, not just posing:

  • In her vegetable patch, hands full of earth, a tomato plant in the background
  • On a hike in the countryside, rucksack on, a panoramic view behind her
  • In her kitchen making fresh pasta (a friend had snapped it spontaneously)

Each photo told a story. Each photo invited a question.

She ditched the group photos where you had to guess which one she was. She ditched the beach photo in sunglasses. She ditched the overexposed car selfie.

The halo effect in action: A great main picture rubs off on your whole profile. When people see an open, friendly face first, they tend to read the bio more generously and are more likely to write a personal first message.

4. Step 2: From cliché to story – crafting your new bio

A profile bio can be short and generic, or much longer and still completely captivating. Sabine’s new bio was considerably longer than her old one. But the new version felt shorter because every single word counted.

Before

"I’m a fun-loving person who enjoys travelling and the great outdoors. I’m looking for someone to share new experiences with. Honesty and a sense of humour are important to me."

After

"I've been learning Italian for a year – not just for holidays, but because I love the sound of the language. On Saturdays, you’ll find me at the farmers' market bright and early (the best tomatoes are gone by half past seven!), while Sundays are for getting lost in a Donna Leon crime novel. I enjoy a good walk, but I'm no serious hiker – for me, it’s all about the journey, and I’ll happily stop for every interesting mushroom on the way. After 22 years of marriage, I’ve started a new chapter and realised: I really like my life. I’m looking for someone who feels the same about theirs and is curious to see how our two lives might fit together. Ask me about my most embarrassing Italian moment – the story is mortifying, but hilarious!"

What made the difference

Swap adjectives for real-life details: "At the farmers' market by 7:30 on a Saturday" beats "I'm active" by a mile.

A nod to fellow fans: Mentioning Donna Leon creates an immediate connection for anyone who knows the books.

Vulnerability: Touching on her divorce, briefly and in a positive light, builds trust.

A conversation starter: "Ask me about my most embarrassing Italian moment" is an invitation, not a demand.

A positive outlook: Instead of making demands ("You must be honest"), she showed what she brought to the table.

5. Step 3: Make your profile mobile-friendly

Sabine wrote her profile on her laptop. It wasn't until her friend opened it on her smartphone that she spotted the problem: the first line of her bio was cut off.

On the phone, it just said: "I've been learning Italian for a year – not just for holidays, but because I love the lan..."

Those first two lines decide if someone will read on. They need to spark curiosity, not just list facts.

The fix

She tried out a few different opening lines:

  • "At the farmers' market by 7:30 on a Saturday, lost in Donna Leon's crime novels on a Sunday."
  • "I'm learning Italian, not for holidays – but because the language feels like music."
  • "After 22 years of marriage, I've started a new chapter and I like my life. Looking for someone who likes theirs too."

The third option was the clear winner. It was personal, positive, and posed an unspoken question: "Do you like your life?"

Sabine also checked how her photos were cropped on a smartphone. Her main photo was landscape, which on the phone was cut down to a tight, unflattering close-up of her face. She swapped it for a portrait version that was much better suited to the mobile view.

Your mobile checklist

  • First two lines: make them an irresistible hook
  • Separate paragraphs with blank lines (a solid block of text can look overwhelming on a phone)
  • Stick to portrait or square photos
  • Read your text through on your own phone

6. The results: An irresistible profile in action

Two weeks after giving her profile an overhaul, Sabine’s online dating experience had completely transformed.

The numbers

(Example figures, not a guarantee)

Profile views: from 47 to 214

Matches: from 2 to 18

First messages: from one-word ‘Hi’s to messages averaging 4-5 sentences, full of specific questions

But the numbers only told half the story.

The quality

She was now getting messages like: “Right, now I need to hear your most embarrassing Italian moment – I had a rather mortifying one in Barcelona myself.” Or: “Donna Leon! I thought I was the only one who devours her books. Which is your favourite?”

Conversations no longer started with generic small talk, but with genuine common ground. Sabine didn't have to struggle to think of things to talk about – her profile had already done the hard work for her.

Her confidence boost

Sabine no longer felt like she was hiding or playing a role.

She was visible – as the person she really was. The response she got confirmed that she was interesting, warm, and absolutely dateable.

After six weeks, she met Michael, a retired architect who replied to her message about Donna Leon's descriptions of Venice with an invitation for a walk along the river. “Your profile was the first one where I felt like I was getting to know a real person,” he said on their first date.

Sabine hadn’t changed her looks, her age, or her life story. She had just stopped hiding.

Since she was looking for a serious relationship, she focused on Match.com and eHarmony – platforms aimed at long-term connections that attract a more mature user base. Investing time in a well-thought-out profile tends to pay off on sites built around longer profiles.

Profile elementBefore (invisible)After (visible)
Main photoSunglasses, face in shadow, holiday snapshotRecent, natural light, genuine smile
About me‘Honesty and a sense of humour are important to me’A specific scene from her daily life that shows this
InterestsGeneric buzzwordsSpecific details that start a conversation
ImpactGets skimmed and swiped awaySticks in the mind and invites a message
Sabine's profile side-by-side: same person, completely different first impression.

7. How to perfect your profile with AskAlva

Sabine's example reflects a common problem. Many singles are in the same boat: they know their profile isn't working, but they can't figure out why.

This is where AskAlva comes in. Our AI dating coach looks at your profile through the eyes of a kind, honest friend, and within seconds shows you how your profile is likely to come across to others.

The AskAlva Profile Check

The AskAlva Profile Check reviews:

Your photos: Are they recent, clear, inviting? Do they show you in action or just posing?

Your bio: Are you using tired clichés that mean you get overlooked? Have you included any conversation starters?

Your next steps: Which three changes will make the biggest difference, and which photos are you still missing?

AskAlva doesn't just explain what’s not working; she shows you how to make it better. She offers specific rewording ideas, photo tips and a list of priorities, so you know which changes will have the biggest impact with the least effort.

AskAlva never judges you as a person; she only reviews how you're presenting yourself. Because you're not the problem. It’s simply that your profile isn’t yet showing people who you really are.

Your first three checks are free (from the second one, you just need to register, which is also free). With AskAlva Pro, you can then keep tweaking it as much as you like, until your profile isn’t just good, but irresistible.

Get your free profile check with AskAlva now

8. Frequently asked questions about perfecting your profile

How often should I update my profile photos?

You should update your profile photos regularly, making sure they still look like you today. Using older photos can make your date feel misled, which is a difficult start to recover from. If your look has changed – say, a new hairstyle, a different weight, or you’ve started wearing glasses – you should swap your pictures straight away. Singles want to know who they’re meeting, not what you looked like a while ago. It’s a good rule of thumb to add new photos after any big change to your appearance, even if your current photos aren’t that old yet.

Why do so many matches go nowhere?

Many matches go nowhere because some singles only log in now and then or aren’t ready to commit yet. A profile with specific details and a clear statement of what you’re looking for helps you reach the singles who are serious about finding someone.

What should I mention about my divorce?

Any information you share about divorce on your profile should be kept brief, positive and forward-looking. A phrase like “Divorced and wiser” or “Starting a new chapter after a long marriage” is all you need. Avoid going into detail about why the relationship ended, assigning blame or offering long explanations, as this can suggest you’re not ready to move on. Often, a single line saying you're divorced is enough. If you want to share more, save it for a private chat. Showing that your divorce is a closed chapter, not an open wound, signals that you’re emotionally available.

How do I know if my profile is being penalised by the algorithm?

You can tell if the algorithm is penalising your profile if you’re getting hardly any profile views despite being active on the site. Possible reasons for this include an incomplete profile, being too selective when you swipe, weeks of inactivity, or complaints from other singles. The solution is to complete your profile, log in regularly, reply to messages and update your photos. Some platforms give new or updated profiles a “boost”, which you should make the most of, as algorithms tend to favour complete and active profiles anyway.

Should I use emojis and formatting in my bio?

You should use emojis, formatting and other visual elements in your bio sparingly to improve readability without looking like you're not taking it seriously. Breaking up paragraphs with blank lines makes your bio much easier to read on a smartphone. However, too many visual gimmicks can seem immature or frivolous, so it’s better to let your words do the talking. Avoid chains of asterisks or symbols that replace whole sentences. A clear paragraph structure and a few well-placed blank lines will boost readability without compromising your profile’s credibility.

What should I do if I don't have any recent photos I like?

If you don’t have any recent photos you like, you can simply ask a friend to help you take some new pictures. You don’t need professional shots, just honest, well-lit photos that show the real you. Pick a day with good weather, wear something you feel comfortable in and get them to take a few dozen snaps of you, perhaps while you're out for a walk or in a café. There are almost always a few good ones among them. The most important things are natural light, a genuine smile and authentic moments rather than staged poses.

How long should my bio be?

Your bio should be long enough to show your personality, but short enough that people will actually read it: on dating sites that often means a few short paragraphs, on dating apps with a character limit just a few sentences. Either way, put the most important information in the first couple of lines. As a rule of thumb: if you wouldn’t want to read your own text, it’s too long or too boring. Keep editing it down until every sentence counts. A tried-and-tested structure is three short paragraphs: Who are you? What do you love to do? Who or what are you looking for?

Why do I only get ‘Hi’ or ‘Hey’ messages?

Getting only ‘Hi’ or ‘Hey’ messages is usually a sign that your profile offers too few specific conversation starters. If your bio is full of clichés like “I’m open and honest”, other singles won’t know what to latch onto. Instead, include concrete details – a hobby, a short anecdote or a question – that give people something to ask you about. The more specific your profile is, the more personal the messages you receive will be, because you make it easier for people to think of an interesting first message.

📸 Profile check by AskAlva

Want to know how your profile comes across? Upload a screenshot. AskAlva gives you honest feedback on photos and bio.

Try it free →

Screenshots are never stored.

More from “Dating profile”